[All] Fw: tentative Cambridge plans to discharge stormwater into Barrie's Lake Wetlands.

Mon Jul 8 15:39:10 EDT 2013

----- Forwarded Message -----
From: Louisette Lanteigne <butterflybluelu at rogers.com>
To: Gregory C. Michalenko <gcmichalenko at uwaterloo.ca> 
Sent: Monday, July 8, 2013 3:38:49 PM
Subject: Re: [All] tentative Cambridge plans to discharge stormwater into Barrie's Lake	Wetlands.

Hi folks

The concern I have for Barrie's Lake is the exact same concern as the West Side Lands. It's the chloride that kills salt sensitive biota that can destroy this wetland complex and/or the biodiversity of the area. ESPA's are protected by policies enshrined in the ROPP and if you augment water quality, flow or flow rates to water features in an ESPA it violates section 4. 3. 15. Here are my experts minutes which were signed off by all parties. The first section is specific to this issue and it is what we used to secure the protection of Vernal pond 12 at the OMB.

http://waterloomoraineact.com/expertminutes.htm

Species like fairy shrimp and Jefferson Salamanders are specifically designed to adapt to occasional drought scenarios. The salamanders live for 35 years and the fairy shrimp enter dormant states when ponds go dry but if you add any measure of salt augmenting the natural ph level these key species and their food sources will die.  During my OMB process my experts used a master's thesis from Wilfrid Laurier that showed clearly how SWM ponds are not suitable breeding grounds for amphibians. The pond studied was the one in my subdivision of Columbia Forest here in Waterloo.

Salt changes the PH balance. It stimulates the growth of algae and destroys salt sensitive species. It also augments freeze/cold cycles because salt water takes longer to freeze than fresh water and that can lead to water decline during winter months. 

Lulu 

________________________________
 From: Gregory C. Michalenko <gcmichalenko at uwaterloo.ca>
To: "all at gren.ca" <all at gren.ca> 
Sent: Friday, July 5, 2013 7:17:51 PM
Subject: Re: [All] tentative Cambridge plans to discharge stormwater into Barrie's Lake	Wetlands.

Dear Grenlings, 

Lulu forwarded a request by a Cambridge group (see below) to oppose stormwater discharge into Barrie's Lake, a fine natural area and marsh just west of Cambridge.  I asked Chris Gosselin, an ecological planner for the Region for clarification of the proposal.  Here's his reply.  ESPA = environmentally sensitive policy area; ESL = Environmentally Sensitive Landscape (a new planning designation covering large areas with valuable natural amenities); EEAC = Ecological and Environmental Advisory Committee.  EEAC has about 16 member volunteers and any proposal in the Region that could affect designated high quality natural areas, such as an ESPA like Barrie's Lake, is subject to evaluation and assessment by EEAC.

It may be appropriate to hold off taking sides or offering comments on this issue until the proposed servicing plan is made public and different options can be considered.  Barrie's Lake is shallow and last year's drought hit it hard.  Hence it is worthwhile considering alternatives to assure stability of water levels and selecting the best option.  Of course, expressing concern and demonstrating that there is public support for maintaining the health of our natural areas is always a good thing.

- Greg Michalenko

________________________________

From: Chris Gosselin [CGosselin at regionofwaterloo.ca]
Sent: Friday, July 05, 2013 4:52 PM
To: Gregory C. Michalenko
Subject: RE: [All] Cambridge plans to discharge stormwater into Barrie's Lake Wetlands.

Hi Greg,
The Cambridge West Master Environmental Servicing Plan is nearing completion. At this time, it is only developing options which will be submitted to the public later this year. One of the conceptual stormwater management scenarios for future development proposes to discharge from a limited area to Barrie’s Lake, and the other only has limited surface flow to maintain water balance. The preferred alternative has yet to be selected and approved. 
Whatever alternative is chosen, Barrie’s Lake is an E.S.P.A. within an E.S.L. As such, any development contiguous to the lake, including any stormwater management plan, will be subject to review by E.E.A.C.  and other agencies. The natural heritage work done to date for the study area has really highlighted the high habitat and wildlife values of the area, Barrie’s Lake included, and the agencies are aware of their responsibilities to protect these features from future development.
Chris 

Christopher Gosselin, M.C.I.P., R.P.P.,
Manager of Environmental Planning,
Planning, Housing, and Community Services Department,
Regional Municipality of Waterloo,
150 Frederick Street,
Kitchener, Ontario, N2G 4J3.
Phone: 519-575-4501
Fax: 519-575-4449

Confidentiality Notice: This e-mail correspondence (including any attachments) may contain information which is confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable law, and is intended only for the use of the designated recipient(s) listed above. Any unauthorised use or disclosure isstrictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, or have otherwise received this message by mistake, please notify the sender by replying via e-mail, and destroy all copies of this original correspondence (including any attachments). Thank you for your co-operation.

NOTE: Ce courriel peut contenir de l'information privilégiée et confidentielle. Si vous avez recu ce message par erreur, veuillez le mentionner immédiatement à l'expéditeur et effacer ce courriel.

_____________________________________________________

SAY NO TO CITY OF CAMBRIDGE PLANS TO DISCHARGE SUBDIVISION STORMWATER INTO BARRIE'S LAKE WETLANDS
The  City of Cambridge has asked the public to send comments on their 255 acre Cambridge West Subdivision plans. The City plans to discharge Stormwater from the proposed Cambridge West Subdivision into Barrie's Lake Wetlands on Roseville Road in North Dumfries. 
Barrie's Lake Environmentally Sensitive Policy Area 57 is:
·        Provincially Significant Wetlands
·        in an Environmentally Sensitive Landscape
·        a vital habitat for fish, wildlife and migratory birds
·        ecologically sensitive and unable to survive this abuse

The turtle population is already at risk. Hundreds of turtles have been killed crossing Roseville Road to lay their eggs. The City has plans for Collector Roads to re-align Blenheim and Roseville Roads between the wetlands in the path of wildlife. Collector Roads may be connected with roundabouts.

70% of Ontario's wetlands have already been destroyed or degraded. In parts of southwestern Ontario, over 90% of the original wetlands are gone. These are among the highest recorded losses of wetlands anywhere on Earth.

Stormwater from heavily populated areas such as subdivisions has been shown to contain harmful substances such as sediment, heavy metals, household cleaning agents, commercial soaps, solvents and paint residues.  

According to the Ministry of Natural Resources "The capacity of wetlands to neutralize harmful substances is limited; too much runoff can degrade or destroy the wetlands killing fish and wildlife."

One Region of Waterloo Councillor has said "there's no way to see if groundwater protection efforts required in developments actually work. Nobody goes back to check."

Please email the City of Cambridge and Say No to Stormwater Discharge into Barrie's Lake.

The public can address comments to the following to become part of the public record.

SouwandA at cambridge.ca        and        dcurrie at mhbcplan.com
519-740-4650  ext 4601                                     519-576 -3650

This plan was only made public on June 18th, 2013. The City of Cambridge wants your comments now.
Planners are going to finalize the preferred options in July.

Only public comments can save the wetlands and wildlife. Please send your comments today.

For more information see the Cambridge West website:
http://www.cambridge.ca/planning_services/planning_operations/cambridge_west_master_environmental_servicing_plan_mesp

_______________________________________________
All mailing list
All at gren.ca
http://mail.gren.ca/mailman/listinfo/all_gren.ca
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://gren.ca/pipermail/all_gren.ca/attachments/20130708/8e1f414c/attachment.html>